Newcastle United

DERMOT GALLAGHER EXAMINES TWO CONTROVERSIAL REFEREEING DECISIONS DURING NEWCASTLE UNITED’S 2-2 DRAW WITH ARSENAL AS FORMER PREMIER LEAGUE REFEREE EXPLAINS WHY THE MAGPIES HAVE EVERY REASON TO FEEL ROBBED!

Dermot Gallagher has cast his expert eye over two hugely controversial refereeing decisions during Newcastle United’s 2-2 draw with Arsenal at St James’ Park, and the former Premier League referee has explained why the Magpies have every reason to feel hard done by.

 

The match itself was a tale of two halves. Arsenal dominated the first period and took the lead through Eberechi Eze, but Newcastle roared back after the break with goals from Harvey Barnes and Malick Thiaw before Noni Madueke rescued a point for the Gunners.

However, the talking points after the game were not the goals, but the decisions of referee Chris Kavanagh and Gallagher was not impressed.

The First Controversy: Joe Willock’s Challenge on Eze

 

The first flashpoint arrived in the 46th minute, with Arsenal already a goal to the good. Joe Willock attempted to take the ball off Eberechi Eze near the edge of the box, and there appeared to be minimal contact. Kavanagh awarded Arsenal a free-kick in a dangerous position, and Martin Odegaard forced a save from Lukas Hornicek.

 

Gallagher was unequivocal in his assessment.

 

“That’s not a foul. Simple as that,” Gallagher said. “Willock barely touches him. Eze goes down, and the referee buys it. It’s a soft decision, and it’s one that put Newcastle under unnecessary pressure right on the stroke of half-time. Those are the moments that can change games.”

 

Gallagher continued: “I’ve watched it back several times, and I still can’t see a foul. Willock is trying to win the ball, Eze is trying to shield it, and there’s minimal contact at best. The referee has been conned. It’s as simple as that. And it’s frustrating because it’s the kind of decision that can swing momentum.”

 

The former referee was asked whether he felt Eze had exaggerated the contact, and his response was measured but pointed.

 

“I don’t want to accuse players of diving. That’s not my place. But I will say this there was very little in it. Very little. And when you see the reaction of the Newcastle players, when you see the reaction of the bench, they were furious. And they had every right to be.”

 

The Second Controversy: Harvey Barnes’ Booking and the Rice Tackle Appeal

 

The second decision that sparked fury on Tyneside came in the 57th minute. Harvey Barnes, who had been Newcastle’s best player, was booked for a challenge on Ezri Konsa. Replays showed Barnes made minimal contact, with Konsa going down holding his shin.

“That’s a yellow card for what? For breathing on him?” Gallagher said. “Barnes is a physical player, he plays the game the right way, and he’s been punished for nothing. Konsa goes down theatrically, the referee falls for it, and Barnes is walking a tightrope for the rest of the game. It’s a poor decision. It’s a really poor decision.”

 

But the controversy did not end there. Moments later, Barnes was involved in a flashpoint with Declan Rice, who lunged into a challenge that sent the Newcastle winger tumbling to the ground. Barnes’s appeal was immediate and furious, throwing his arms up and demanding a free-kick, but Kavanagh waved play on.

 

Gallagher was asked about the appeal, and his response was pointed.

 

“I’ve looked at it again, and Newcastle have every right to feel aggrieved. Rice goes to ground, he takes the man, and the referee doesn’t give it. And then moments earlier, he books Barnes for a nothing challenge. It’s inconsistent. It’s frustrating. And it’s exactly the kind of decision that makes managers and fans feel like they’ve been robbed.”

 

He continued: “The Barnes appeal is a clear foul. Rice doesn’t get the ball. He takes Barnes out. And the referee is standing right there. He’s got a perfect view. And he waves play on. That’s not good enough. That’s not good enough at this level.”

 

Gallagher was also asked whether he felt Barnes’s earlier booking influenced Kavanagh’s decision not to give the foul.

 

“I think it might have done,” Gallagher admitted. “Once you’re on a yellow card, referees sometimes hesitate. They don’t want to give a second yellow unless it’s absolutely necessary. But that’s not how it should work. You give the foul if it’s a foul. You don’t let the earlier decision affect your judgment. And I think that’s what happened here.”

The former referee was also asked about the wider performance of Kavanagh, and his response was pointed.

 

“I don’t like to criticise referees. I’ve been there. I know how hard the job is. But tonight, there were three or four decisions that went against Newcastle, and they were all in key moments. The Willock free-kick, the Barnes yellow, the Rice challenge that wasn’t given. These are the moments that decide games. And Newcastle have every right to feel aggrieved.”

 

Gallagher continued: “Newcastle fought back from a goal down. They showed character. They showed quality. And they deserved more from that game. But when decisions go against you like that, it’s hard to take. It’s really hard to take.”

 

The former referee concluded with a message to the PGMOL, urging them to review the performance.

 

“I think Chris Kavanagh will look back at that game and admit he got a few things wrong. And I think the PGMOL should look at it too. Because Newcastle have every reason to feel robbed tonight. And that’s not something you want to hear after a game like that.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button